Second Thoughts Episode 5 – SHINE 5

Play

Second Thoughts is a podcast where the Squared Circle Sirens team rewatches old women’s wrestling shows and provides a review knowing what we know about the company today. Knowing about the future of the company provides an interesting dynamic to the review.

In Shine 5, we find out if Kimberly really is better as a tag team wrestler than a singles competitor. We see the debut of Ivelisse. Will Rain and Mercedes be able to coexist when they take on Jazz and her mystery partner?

Five volumnes into our Shine reviews, Dennis has put together some statistics. We are tracking our average match ratings, average show ratings, and our top individual matches. We’ll be updating this information every 5 volumes or so.

    Top Shine Matches as of Shine 5

Match Competitors; Shine Volume; Average Rating; Dennis Rating; Scott Rating
Rain and Mercedes Martinez vs Awesome Kong and Jazz – Shine 5 – 4.625 (4.5/4.75)
Jazz vs Mercedes Martinez – Shine 2 – 4.375 (4/4.75)
Jazz vs Sara Del Ray – Shine 1 – 4.25 (3.75/4.75)
Made In Sin vs. MsEerie – Shine 2 – 4.12 (4/4.25)
Ivelisse vs Athena – Shine 5 -4.0 (3.75/4.25)
Leva Bates vs Portia Perez – Shine 2 – 4.0 (3.75/4.25)
Made In Sin vs Leva Bates and Kimberly – Shine 5 – 3.875 (4/3.75)
Rain vs Nikki Roxx – Shine 1 – 3.875 (3.75/4)
Mercedes Martinez vs Jayme Jameson – Shine 3- 3.75 (3.75/3.75)
Jazz vs Rain – Shine 3 – 3.75 (3.5/4)
Jessicka Havok vs Mia Yim – Shine 3 – 3.75 (4/3.5)
Mercedes Martinez vs Leva Bates – Shine 1 – 3.75 (3.5/4)
Jazz vs Saraya Knight – Shine 4 – 3.625 (3.75/3.5)
Jessicka Havok vs Nikki Roxx – Shine 5- 3.625 (3.25/4)
Made In Sin vs WCC – Shine 1 – 3.5 (3.5/3.5)

    Dennis Top 5 As of Shine 5:

Rain and Mercedes vs Kong and Jazz – Shine 5
Made in Sin vs Leva and Kimberly – Shine 5
Jazz vs Mercedes Martinez – Shine 2
Havok vs Mia Yim – Shine 3
Made in Sin vs MsEerie – Shine 2

    Scott Top 5 as of Shine 5:

Rain and Mercedes v Jazz and Amazing Kong – Shine 5
Jazz v Sara Del Rey – Shine 1
Mercedes v Jazz Shine 2
Ivelisse v Athena – Shine 5
Portia Perez v Leva Bates – Shine 2

    Top 5 Cards as of Shine 5:

Shine 5 – 3.625 (3.25/4)
Shine 2 – 3.33 (3/3.375)
Shine 1 – 3.17 (2.75/3.5)
Shine 3 – 3.17 (2.75/3.5)
Shine 4 – 2.5 (2.25/2.75)

Talk to Scott on Twitter.
Talk to Dennis on Twitter.

Let us know what you think using #SCSThoughts and #SecondThoughts.

Music Credit: Iron Horse on Purple Planet Music.

You might also like More from author